YThe Great NYC Yogurt + Fruit Map

Shareable yogurt guide

A-tier

Bellwether Farms

Sheep milk

High-butterfat sheep milk gives it richness without heavy straining.

Tangbright
Bodycreamy
Milksheep
Bellwether Farms Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt in a cream-colored 16-ounce tub with a sheep illustration
Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt · photo source ↗

New York City

Where to find Bellwether Farms

Listings were checked against makers, retailers or current market schedules. Small-batch stock still changes fast.

Build the bowl

What to put on it

Whip a generous sprinkle of Maldon into the yogurt first. Then add fruit.

William’s guide

Figs + dark, high-acid grapes

Velvety figs need the zig of genuinely sour grapes. Skip bland table grapes and look for darker, high-acid fruit.