Union Square · check
Whole Foods Market — Union Square
4 Union Square S, New York, NY 10003The White Moustache maker locator lists this branch. Nancy’s and Painterland have chain-level Whole Foods distribution; call for exact flavors.
Shareable yogurt guide
S-tierNancy’s
European & Greek cow milk
Whole-milk, low-fat and nonfat styles with a distinct probiotic-culture tang.
Tangsharp
Bodycreamy
Milkcow
New York City
Where to find Nancy’s
Listings were checked against makers, retailers or current market schedules. Small-batch stock still changes fast.
Brooklyn Heights · verified listing
Foodtown — Brooklyn Heights
101 Clinton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201The surprise supermarket jackpot: current catalogs show White Mountain, both regular and Greek Nancy’s, Bellwether sheep yogurt, and Seven Stars.
Lower East Side · check
Whole Foods Market — Bowery
95 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002The White Moustache maker locator lists this branch. Painterland has a direct Whole Foods product page and Nancy’s is chain-level, so check exact flavors.
Build the bowl
What to put on it
Whip a generous sprinkle of Maldon into the yogurt first. Then add fruit.
Green Gage plums + blackberries
Soft, jelly-centered plums meet tart late blackberries: lush texture with an acidic lift.