Flatiron · check
Eataly Flatiron
200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010Strong one-stop retail bet. White Mountain, Bellwether and White Moustache have current product pages; exact stock fluctuates. Berle is a listed partner—call first.
Shareable yogurt guide
S-tierThe White Moustache
Persian & Greek cow milk
The guide's NYC GOAT: handmade, lush and tangy.
Tangbright
Bodydense
Milkcow
New York City
Where to find The White Moustache
Listings were checked against makers, retailers or current market schedules. Small-batch stock still changes fast.
Union Square · check
Whole Foods Market — Union Square
4 Union Square S, New York, NY 10003The White Moustache maker locator lists this branch. Nancy’s and Painterland have chain-level Whole Foods distribution; call for exact flavors.
SoHo · verified listing
Happier Grocery
365 Canal St, New York, NY 10013Highest-yield downtown shop: Sourmilk's first grocery account, plus White Moustache, Larson, Blue Pepper, Erivan, and current Straus European and Greek listings.
Park Slope · seasonal
Park Slope Food Coop
782 Union St, Brooklyn, NY 11215An unusually deep seasonal selection, but shopping is generally member-only.
Lower East Side · seasonal
Union Market — Lower East Side
240 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002Sourmilk names this current account, Willow Pond lists it for its April–October season, and the White Moustache maker locator includes it.
Upper West Side · seasonal
Zabar’s
2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024The White Moustache maker locator lists Zabar’s; Willow Pond independently confirms it as a seasonal account. Call for same-day stock.
Lower East Side · check
Whole Foods Market — Bowery
95 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002The White Moustache maker locator lists this branch. Painterland has a direct Whole Foods product page and Nancy’s is chain-level, so check exact flavors.
Greenwich Village · verified listing
Citarella — West Village
424 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011Citarella currently lists several White Moustache yogurts for pickup or delivery; Sourmilk says it is now in every Citarella location.
Build the bowl
What to put on it
Whip a generous sprinkle of Maldon into the yogurt first. Then add fruit.
Figs + dark, high-acid grapes
Velvety figs need the zig of genuinely sour grapes. Skip bland table grapes and look for darker, high-acid fruit.